Most Wished-For Gifts You’ll Want on Your Wishlist

Images of Elfster's Most Wished For Gifts
Updated 4/1/24

Elfster’s Most Wished-For Gifts

Ready, set, wish! These most wished-for gifts from our most popular gift guides are perfect to give as a gift or add to your own Wishlist. Creating your own Elfster Wishlist is a fun, free and stress-free way to let everyone know what you really want for birthdays or any gifting occasion! 

We’ve rounded up the most popular gifts Elfster fans are wishing for right now. Add ’em to your own Wishlist for gifts you’re guaranteed to love unwrapping!

GIFT: e.l.f. Cosmetics Glow Reviver Lip Oil

Want to give your lips an e.l.f.-y glow? Elfster beauty lovers are puckering up for e.l.f. Cosmetics Glow Reviver Lip Oil for its hydrating shine, making this glow-inducing gift one of our most wished! Find this gotta-have-it gift for your best smile in our exclusive Gift Guide.

e.l.f. Cosmetics glow revival lip oil

e.l.f. Cosmetics Glow Reviver Lip Oil |, $8

GIFT: 18K Gold Plated Clover Bracelet
Bracelets and Watches

The leaves of four-leaf clovers are said to stand for faith, hope, love, and luck. This stylish clover bracelet is a lucky charm you can carry on your wrist. You’ll find it in our Bracelets and Watches Gift Guide.

Lucky clover bracelet

18K Gold Plated Clover Bracelet | Amazon, $13.98

GIFT: Aloe Vera Eye Mask
Mother’s Day

Aloe Eye Masks for the WIN as one of Elfster’s Most Wished-For Gifts of the year! These soothing eye masks will refresh your skin & radiate cheer, making them a perfect gift for mom or someone else who could use a little self care. Find them in our Mother’s Day Gift Guide.

Aloe vera eye masks

Aloe Vera Eye Mask | Amazon, $9.99

GIFT: Tie Dye Nike Socks

These socks rock and are an Elfster fan fave! Available in a variety of muted colors, the bestselling Tie Dye Nike Sock collection is perfect for aesthetic and fun loungewear! Every pair is custom made to order by an an Etsy seller who is passionate about adding a dash of delightful color into your wardrobe for ultimate style!

Tie dye Nike socks

Tie Dye Nike Socks | Etsy, $11.99

GIFT: LEGO Cherry Blossom
$25 and Under Favorites

Fun for all ages, these buildable blooms will never wilt! These LEGO Cherry Blossom beauties are full of spring inspo and take creativity to a new level, making it a favorite $25 and under gift.

LEGO Cherry Blossom building set

LEGO Cherry Blossom | Amazon, $11.99

GIFT: Sol de Janeiro Bum Bum Jet Set
Trending Gifts – 2024

Get that warm, beachy scent with this award-winning Bum Bum Travel Set as you jet your way to summer adventures. Elfster fans find this body care set that visibly firms skin irresistible and love its sunny scent, making it a top Trending Gift for 2024.

Sol de Janeiro Brazilian Bum Bum Cream

Sol de Janeiro Bum Bum Jet Set | Amazon, $30

GIFT: Personalized 40 oz. Tumbler
$25 – $50

Keep your drinks North Pole cold all day long with this personalized personalized tumbler. It holds 40 oz. so you’ll stay hydrated, plus the narrow base fits in any car cup holder. Find this personalized gift that’s perfect for friends (or even yourself) in our $25-$50 Gift Guide.

Personalized 40 oz. tumbler engraved by Etsy seller

Personalized 40 oz. Tumbler | Etsy, $30.75+

GIFT: Kitsch Mini Face & Ice Roller Set
Skin Care

Take skin care to a new level with this Kitsch Mini Face & Ice Roller Set from a woman-owned brand that focuses on sustainable beauty solutions for every moment of the day. The eco-friendly set includes an Ice Roller for cool soothing, as well as a Silicone Roller to massage, making this a top wish in our Skin Care Gift Guide.

Kitsch spa roller set

Kitsch Mini Face & Ice Roller Set | Amazon, $12.77

GIFT: Reusable Glass Tumbler Set
$25 & Under Coffee & Tea Mugs

Great on the go, these eco-friendly glasses come with bamboo lids and glass straws are super convenient for a healthy morning smoothie, yummy boba tea or an iced coffee. With summer right around the corner, this top pick in our $25 & Under Coffee & Tea Mugs gift guide makes a great gift or the perfect party favor.

Scoozee glass tumblers for iced coffee or tea

Reusable Glass Tumbler Set | Amazon, $16.99

GIFT: Makeup Brush Set
Tools and Brushes

Whether you’re a beauty beginner or makeup pro, this 18-piece makeup brush set will be your go-to! Put your best face forward with this versatile set that’s a most-wished gem in our Tools and Brushes Gift Guide.

Most wished-for 18-piece makeup brush set

18-piece Makeup Brush Set | Amazon, $9.98

GIFT: Glass Plant Mister
Plants & Gardening

Plant parents are growing fond of this glass plant mister that’s perfect for watering everything from potted plants to precious perennials. This garden must-have is just one of the great gifts for Spring in our Plants & Gardening Gift Guide.

Glass spray bottle to use as plant mister

Glass Plant Mister | Amazon, $11.99

GIFT: Rechargeable Makeup Mirror
Gadget Girl

This handy light-up makeup mirror gives you the perfect prop to check your look wherever your adventures may lead. And whether you’re packing light or bringing it all, this top wish in our Gadget Girl Gift Guide is a space saver that’s easy to charge too.

Rechargeable makeup mirror

Rechargeable Makeup Mirror | Amazon, $16.99

GIFT: Connecticut Home Company Shag Throw Blanket
Home Decor

Who says cozy season can’t last all year? Take a soothing moment to curl up with this ultra-plush shag throw blanket featured in our Home Decor Gift Guide. It’s just the accent to add a layer of texture or pop of color to your comfy space.

Shag throw blanket in dusty rose color hanging over leather chair

Connecticut Home Company Shag Throw Blanket | Amazon, $19.95

GIFT: Positive Affirmations Cards
Astrology Lovers

Empower your soul with positive vibes! Your daily dose of self-care featured in our Astrology Lovers Gift Guide is channeled into this set of 36 poetically-inspired positive affirmations cards  to encourage you to live your days to their fullest potential.

Set of 36 positive affirmation cards to improve mindfulness

Positive Affirmations Cards | Amazon, $16.95

GIFT: Chicken Shredder
Kitchen Gadgets

Cut meal prep time in half with this game-changing Chicken Shredder from our Kitchen Gadgets Gift Guide.  This gadget is the perfect tool to quickly make restaurant favorites at home like tacos, enchiladas, pulled pork sandwiches and more.

Chicken shredding machine

Chicken Shredder | Amazon, $19.99

GIFT: USB Rechargeable Electric Candle Lighter
$25 and Under Candles

A gift that literally sparks joy! No wonder this USB Rechargeable Electric Candle Lighter was our overall “most wished-for” gift in 2022 with over 54,000 wishes! You’ll find this hot wish in our $25 and Under Candles Gift Guide.

USB Rechargeable Electric Candle Lighter is Elfster's most wished-for gift in 2022

USB Rechargeable Electric Candle Lighter | Amazon, $10.00

GIFT: Aromatherapy Soy Wax Candle Set
GIFT GUIDE: $25 and Under Candles

This aromatherapy soy wax candle set has been burning up our $25 and Under Candles Gift Guide. Cleanse your home of negative energy and infuse with the calming scents of sage and lavender that will help to relax and wind down from your stresses.

Aromatherapy Soy Wax Candle Set | Amazon, $17.99

GIFT: Wooden Book Page Holder
GIFT GUIDE: Gifts for Book Lovers

Always have your nose in a book? This simple, but clever Wooden Book Page Holder will help keep the pages wide open for an easy read! It’s featured in our Gifts for Book Lovers Gift Guide and makes a perfect gift for your book club besties too!

Wooden Book Page Holder for book lovers

Wooden Book Page Holder | Amazon, $10.99

GIFT: Morphe 18T Truth or Bare Artistry Palette
Ulta – Makeup

Our beauty Elfsters have spoken and the beyond-blendable neutral shades of this Morphe 18T Truth or Bare Artistry Palette is the perfect look for any occasion. Our Ulta – Makeup features all the beauty must-haves to glow all year long!

Morphe 18T Truth or Bare Artistry Palette from as a most wished-for gift

Morphe 18T Truth or Bare Artistry Palette | Ulta, $20

GIFT: Incohearent Family Edition
Family Games

This party game where you compete to guess the gibberish is the perfect addition to a hilarious family game night. Incohearent Family Edition is the best selling game that’s topping our Family Games Gift Guide and taking social media by storm.

Incohearent family game

Incohearent Family Edition | Amazon, $19.99

GIFT: The Stay-at-Home Chef Slow Cooker Cookbook
GIFT GUIDE: Cookbooks

Time to create simple and hearty recipes that will appeal to anyone who is short on time, but still wants to enjoy delicious meals at home. Every recipe in The Stay at Home Chef Slow Cooker Cookbook featured in our Cookbooks Gift Guide uses everyday ingredients and features simple instructions.

The Stay at Home Chef Slow Cooker Cookbook cover

The Stay-At-Home Chef Slow Cooker Cookbook | Amazon, $12.59

GIFT: Waterproof Shower Phone Holder
GIFT GUIDE: TikTok Finds

This genius life hack is really making a splash in our TikTok Finds Gift Guide. This anti-fog phone holder mounts right on the wall in your shower so you can listen to your fave podcast or playlist as you get ready to start your busy day, no bluetooth speaker required.

Waterproof phone holder for shower to add to wishlist

Waterproof Shower Phone Holder | Amazon, $11.99

GIFT: Zodiac Star Sign Socks 
GIFT GUIDE: Astrology Lovers

Our Elfster astrology experts are seeing stars over these Zodiac Star Sign Socks! These comfy-cozies are out of this world and are available for each of the zodiac signs, making it a stellar hit in our Astrology Lovers Gift Guide.

Zodiac star sign socks for wishlist

Zodiac Star Sign Socks | Uncommon Goods, $12.00

Looking for More Gifts to Add to Your Wishlist?

Elfster's Trending gift guides

Explore our Trending Gift Guides to find popular picks and most wished-for gifts! And Elfsters: these gifts are a perfect addition to your own Elfster Wishlist to be sure you get what you really want.

✨ELF TIP✨  Keep your eyes on this space – we’ll be updating with new gifts all year!

Connect with Elfster for gifts, giveaways, and great news on Facebook and Instagram.

Elfster may earn a small commission through clicks or purchases made to external sites, which helps keep the workshop humming. Read More

About Meghan L 213 Articles
Meghan L has been elfing it since she joined the team in 2009. She enjoys coordinating exchanges, talking to organizers, and all things Christmas. Join her for an eggnog latte anytime at