Will You Be Mine? 9 Gifts for Your Valentine’s Day Wishlist

Valentine's lip balm set in three colors
Valentine’s Day Lip Balm Set | Ulta Beauty

Want a gift you truly love from your sweetheart? Creating a Valentine’s Day Wishlist on Elfster is the place to start. Wish for gifts like the ones below. Then share it with your cutie so they’re in the know!

Gifts to Add to Your Valentine’s Day Wishlist

Looking for something sentimental? Traditional? Or how about something whimsical to express yourself? Our Valentine’s Day Gift Guide features gifts that we’re sure will sweeten your day!

GIFT: The Love Potion Candle

Valentine’s Mewd: Spark Love! This Love Potion Candle unleashes the sweet scents of citrus, cherry blossom and vanilla – and it’s topped with romantic gemstones sure to ignite your passion.

The Love Potion candle with romantic gemstones on top for Valentine's Day Gift

The Love Potion Candle | Uncommon Goods, $19.99

GIFT: Valentine’s Day Lip Balm Set

Pucker up for this limited-edition KylieSkin by Kylie Jenner Valentine’s Collection Lip Balm Set. It contains three sweet flavors: Strawberry, Candy Heart and Cherry, leaving your lips kissable all day!

Valentine's Lip Balm Set by KylieSkin in three shades of red

Valentine’s Day Lip Balm Set | Ulta Beauty, $14.50

GIFT: Heart-Shaped Cordless Magic Bulb Light

We’re in love with this magical heart-shaped light that casts a warm pink glow in your space. It’s USB rechargeable, making it a perfect nighlight or romantic accent light.

Image of light bulb that contains heart shaped filament for Valentine's Day Gift

Heart-Shaped Cordless Magic Bulb Light | Urban Outfitters, $40

GIFT: Band of Hearts Ring

Wrapped around your finger, this delicate band of hearts ring makes a simple yet elegant statement. Stack a few to create a chic look of love.

Woman wearing Band of Hearts ring from Pandora

Band of Hearts Ring | Pandora, $35


This Libre Eau de Parfum scent statement is for women who do what they want and dare to be exactly who they are. Combining lavender essence with the sensual citrus of Moroccan orange blossom, it makes for a delightful floral fusion.

Perfume bottle with Yves Saint Laurent logo embellishment

YVES SAINT LAURENT Libre Eau de Parfum | Nordstrom, $30 & up

GIFT: Chicago Metallic S’mores Maker

Indulge in a classic sweet treat with this charming and innovative indoor S’mores Maker. Delicious S’mores are just a few steps away, no campsite required.

Indoor smores maker with marshmallows, chocolate and graham crackers

Chicago Metallic S’mores Maker | Amazon, $30.60

GIFT: Mickey Mouse Love Mug

Who wouldn’t LOVE to sip their morning bev out of this Mickey Mouse Mug? In the words of the world’s most loveable and influential mouse, “I will always be there with you, right there in your heart.”

Coffee mug with the word love using Mickey Mouse ears

Mickey Mouse Love Mug | Shop Disney, $19.99

GIFT: Bella Heart Mini Waffle Maker

Start Valentine’s Day on a sweet note with this mini waffle maker from Bella. It cooks four yummy heart-shaped waffles in no time for the kids (or kids at heart!)

Mini heart shaped waffle maker with red hearts on cover

Bella Heart Mini Waffle Maker | Macy’s, $19.99

GIFT: Snuggle Up Footsie Blanket

Better Together! This Snuggle Up Footsie Blanket for two has all the warm feels. With a secret pocket, you and your favorite snuggler can keep your tootsies toasty together!

Red heart shaped blankets laid flat

Snuggle Up Footsie Blanket | Uncommon Goods, $148

Looking for More Gifts to add to your Valentine’s Day Wishlist?

Screenshot of Valentine's Day Gift Guide from Elfster website

For more LOVE-ly gifts to add to your Valentine’s Day Wishlist, check out our Valentine’s Day Gift Guide. If you’re celebrating with friends, be sure to check out our Galentine’s Day gift ideas, too. And Lovebirds: be sure to share your Elfster Wishlist with your sweetheart to be sure you get what you really want.

Elfster may receive a small commission for any clicks or purchases made on an affiliate website using links on our site.

If you’re looking for more great ways to celebrate Valentine’s Day, connect with Elfster on Facebook, on Twitter @Elfster, or on Instagram @Elfster.

About Meghan L 213 Articles
Meghan L has been elfing it since she joined the team in 2009. She enjoys coordinating exchanges, talking to organizers, and all things Christmas. Join her for an eggnog latte anytime at Elfster.com